Calgary Prime Gold often meets people holding a drawer of sterling silver flatware they inherited and never used. A boxed set of forks and spoons can sit untouched for decades. Before you sell it, the first job is to confirm what you actually have. Solid silver and plated pieces look alike but are very different in value. This guide shows how to identify sterling silver flatware at home and what to expect when you bring a set to one of our Calgary stores.
Sterling Silver Flatware vs. Silver Plate
This is the single most important distinction. Sterling is solid silver, 92.5 percent pure, all the way through. Silver plate is a thin silver layer bonded over a base metal such as nickel or copper.
The difference matters because value comes from recoverable metal. A solid fork holds real silver throughout. A plated fork holds only a trace. Telling them apart before you sell saves disappointment and a wasted trip across the city.
Where These Sets Came From
Most Canadian homes gathered flatware through weddings, estates and gifts over the decades. Plated sets were common for everyday use. Solid sets were often saved for holidays and special occasions. That history is why so many drawers hold a mix of both, and why checking first is worth the effort.
It is also why a single household can own several patterns at once. One set may have come from a grandmother, another from a wedding registry, and a third from an estate sale. Each set can be solid or plated, so the marks matter more than where a piece came from. Sorting by stamp rather than by memory is the reliable way to know what you hold.
How to Identify Sterling Silver Flatware at Home
You can narrow it down in a few minutes with good light and a magnifier.
Read the Marks on Each Piece
Turn each piece over and look at the back of the handle or the underside of the bowl. Solid pieces are marked STERLING, STER or 925. Canadian marking rules for these stamps are set out in the federal Precious Metals Marking Act, which governs how silver content is declared on goods sold in Canada.
Watch for other marks too. EPNS stands for electroplated nickel silver, which is plate. Words like silverplate, A1 or stainless also mean the piece is not solid.
Look for Signs of Plating Wear
On plated pieces, the silver layer wears thin at the edges and the raised points. You may see a darker or coppery metal showing through. Solid pieces wear evenly and never reveal a different metal underneath. Worn edges that show another colour are a strong sign of plate.
Age can help too, though it is not proof on its own. Many older heirloom sets are solid, while a good number of mid-century everyday sets are plated. When the stamp and the wear pattern agree, you can be fairly confident before you even leave the house. When they disagree, bring the piece in and let a test settle it.
A Quick Reference for Common Marks
Use this table to sort your drawer before you visit either store.
| Mark on the piece | What it means | Solid silver? |
|---|---|---|
| STERLING, STER, 925 | 92.5 percent silver | Yes |
| 800, 830, 900 | Continental silver, slightly lower purity | Yes |
| EPNS, A1, silverplate | Thin silver over base metal | No |
| STAINLESS, INOX | Stainless steel | No |
Industry estimates suggest a large share of vintage flatware sold in Canada is plated rather than solid. Checking first is well worth the few minutes it takes.
Hollow Handles and Weighted Bases
Some knives and serving pieces have hollow handles filled with a resin or cement for balance. The handle may be solid silver on the outside, but the filler inside has no metal value. Our team notes these pieces separately so only the silver is assessed. The same applies to weighted candlesticks, though those fall outside a flatware set.
Which Pieces Hold the Most Silver
Not every piece in a set carries the same amount of metal. Serving pieces are usually the heaviest, so they often hold the most silver. Teaspoons and small forks hold the least. Knowing this helps you set fair expectations before you visit.
Here is a rough guide to how a typical solid set breaks down by weight.
| Piece type | Relative silver weight | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Serving spoons and ladles | High | Large, solid pieces |
| Dinner forks and spoons | Medium | The bulk of most sets |
| Teaspoons and small forks | Low | Light but still solid |
| Hollow-handled knives | Variable | Only the silver shell counts |
How We Assess Sterling Silver Flatware
When you bring a set in, the process is open and you watch each step. We sort solid pieces from plated ones, confirm the silver content and weigh the solid items together. You can see the full range on our sterling silverware page, and our open process explains each step before you arrive.
What to Bring
Bring the flatware and a piece of government photo identification. You do not need the box, the receipt or a complete set. Odd and mismatched pieces are welcome, since each is assessed on its silver weight. Serving spoons, cake knives and ladles often hold more silver than a teaspoon, so include those too.
Honest Expectations
The silver market moves daily with global demand, so we never quote a figure before we see and weigh your pieces. As a rule of thumb, the value sits in solid items, not in plated ones. We give you an honest assessment in person after testing, and there is never any pressure to accept it. If a buyer quotes a figure for a set they have not seen, treat that as a warning sign.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know if my flatware is sterling silver?
Look for STERLING, STER or 925 stamped on the back of the handle or the underside of a spoon. That mark means 92.5 percent silver. If you only see EPNS, silverplate or stainless, the item is plated or a base metal.
Is silver-plated flatware worth the same as sterling?
No. Silver plate has only a thin coating over a base metal, so its recoverable silver content is very small. Sterling is solid silver throughout, and that is where the value sits.
Do you buy incomplete sterling sets?
Yes. You do not need a full set. Odd spoons, single forks and serving pieces are all assessed on their silver weight. A partial set is still worth bringing in.
Should I polish sterling flatware before selling it?
There is no need. Tarnish sits on the surface and does not change the silver content underneath. Heavy polishing can wear the metal, so bring pieces as they are.
Visit Calgary Prime Gold
Not sure if that boxed set is solid or plated? Bring it in and we will check it for free. Calgary Prime Gold has two locations: 5940 Macleod Trail SW, Suite 500, Calgary, AB and 1026 16th Ave NW, Suite 203, Calgary, AB. We are open Monday to Saturday, 9:30 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.. Call (403) 630-4653 or request a free quote online, and we reply within 24 hours.
Walk in to either Calgary store or get a free quote based on today’s live price.